• Dr. Guy
  • Why the Q?
  • Appearances
  • Press
  • MusiQologY
  • Writings
  • Contact

Dr. Guy's MusiQologY

~ Where Music's Past & Present Collide

Dr. Guy's MusiQologY

Tag Archives: leroi jones

Session 1: What is African American Music and How Does It Mean?

16 Sunday Sep 2012

Posted by MusiQologY in African American Music, Black Music Research, Funk, Gospel, Hip-Hop, Jazz, R&B, Soul, The Blues

≈ 14 Comments

Tags

African American Music History, Burton Peretti, Eileen Southern, Green Dolphin Street, Guthrie Ramsey, Katie Left Memphis, leroi jones, Mark Anthony Neal, Melonee Burnim, Olly Wilson, Race Music, Ron Radano, Samuel Floyd, The Gap Band, Yearning for Your Love

During the next few weeks I’ll be posting about the course I’m teaching on African American music.  Designed as a survey, it will trace developments from slavery to the present for a mix of music majors and non-majors.  The course begins with some philosophical issues about black music making in the United States, moves through eighteenth, nineteenth, twentieth, and twenty-first-century forms and practices.  We’ll conclude the course with a study of Mark Anthony Neal, a scholar whose work on music in the black public sphere has inspired a powerful generation of young scholars in the field.   All of this is laying the groundwork for a new book on black music and other expressive arts such as poetry, visual art, and film, which will cover the same historical period as the course, and of which I’m about 10,000 words in.  What I’ll share in the weekly posts will represent only a summary of musical, theoretical, and philosophical issues that we cover.  And of course, the ideas I share only form the foundation or spine of the book.  For example, the work on Mark Anthony Neal will help us understand a framework for thinking through the work of other contemporary scholars.

Here’s a broad description.

This course explores aspects of the origins, style development, aesthetic philosophies, historiography, and contemporary conventions of African-American musical traditions. Topics covered include: the music of colonial America, 19th-century church and dance music, minstrelsy, music of the Harlem Renaissance, jazz, blues, gospel, the rhythm and blues constellation of idioms, and hip-hop.  Special attention is given to the ways that black music produces “meaning” and to how the social energy circulating within black music articulates myriad issues about American identity at specific historical moments.  The course will also engage other expressive art forms from visual and literary sources in order to better position music making into the larger framework of African American aesthetic practices.  We will read about and study visual art by African American artists from each period or thematic topic that we cover together with examples of poetry and film.

There have been many retrospectives written on black music in the United States from LeRoi Jones’ Blues People (1963) to Eileen Southern’s The Music of Black Americans (1971) to Samuel Floyd’s The Power of Black Music (1995).  We might also add to this list Mark Anthony Neal’s What the Music Said (1999); Ronald Radano’s Lying Up a Nation (2003); Guthrie Ramsey’s Race Music (2003); and most recently Melonee Burnim’s and Portia Maultsby’s African American Music (2006) and Burton W. Peretti’s Lift Every Voice (2009).  Of course, there are many others, particularly those focusing on single musicians and/or genres.  This wealth of knowledge has contributed powerfully to our understanding the repertories, creators, methods of dissemination, institutional structures, and reception histories of this body of music.  And the philosophical arguments—whether explicitly stated or not—in these studies offer a robust and sometimes contradictory set of notions about the myths of origins, social functions, and aesthetic systems of valuation for the music.

I always try to keep in mind this fundamental question, borrowed from the late English musicologist Christopher Small: “Why are these people making this music in this time at the place?” This query has guided my inquiries and teaching since graduate school, and it has always helped me to begin new projects and new courses.  It’s a wonderful equation that momentarily helps students to sidestep a reaction that many bring to the table in a history course on music—and that is whether they “like” the music in question or not.  When we deal with “people”—the musicians and their audiences—we try to understand the many tributaries and social experiences that comprise their identities.  Identity means here not a “Self” born and evolved in a social and cultural vacuum or reduced to a “skin-color” or sex.  It is, rather, the sum of the identifications made by (or made for) individuals from the range of cultural and social formations available to them at specific historical and moments and locations.  “Music” in this equation is, for me, a most important factor.  I insist that above all, the sonic formations—what precise things musicians do with sound and what audiences make of them requires us to make this a big part of the discussion and not ancillary to it.  Why would one have to say this in a musical study?  Because musical sound—instrumental, vocal, and otherwise—is a discourse that signifies meaning.  And this discourse (music) might do more powerfully sometimes than, say, the truth claim of a song lyric or even what musicians or critics say about the work.

All said, I wish to frame my thoughts here as a “criticism of black music.” A criticism of black music attempts to explain the cultural work the music performs in the social world.   This musico-cultural criticism ultimately seeks to explain what these various styles and gestures mean and how they generate and achieve their signifying affect.  It exposes some of the critical spaces left by earlier models and analytical methods, first by identifying a work’s significant musical gestures and then positioning those gestures within a broader field of musical rhetoric and conventions.  These musico-narrative conventions can then be theorized with respect to broader systems of cultural knowledge, such as the historical contexts in which a musical text or style appeared and the lived experiences of audiences, composers, performers, dancers, and listeners.  Thus, black musical criticism leaves no aspect of the musical process–creation, mediation, reception–untouched, and this fact alone frustrates anyone’s claim that a single study can provide “the” definitive account of a musical topic.  This analytical project provides alternative ways for scholars of black music history to access and discuss some of the historically and socially contingent meanings generated by a musical style and its surrounding practices.

Any study of African American expressive practices must deal head on with the topic of race in America, certainly one of the much-discussed, yet easily misunderstood, aspects of identity and identifications (except, perhaps, sexual orientation).  I work with three broad manifestations of the “race idea”: social race, cultural race, and theoretical race.  Social Race: constitutes the lived experience of race in the everyday realm. This experience is contingent on many factors, including place and historical moment, among others.  The term tries to capture how social experiences mediate group and individual identities and, in turn, affirm who a group thinks it is in the world.   Cultural Race speaks to the explicitly performative and expressive realm of the social experience. These compelling, performed gestures (be they acted out in speech, music, or dance, etc.) allow our social identities a kind of materiality.  Theoretical Race comprises the densely theoretical, postmodern exegesis of race, particularly ones that privilege the society’s structural role over the historical agent’s self-fashioning, as in the much-used phrase “social construction.”  We can ask the same kinds of questions of this particular academic practice as we can of any other action: what cultural work are these theories doing for their audiences and practitioners?

There’s never a perfect way to enter into discussions of musical meaning.  In the first two chapters of my book Race Music, I offer ways into the topic of a sociological interpretation of black music or, perhaps better, the social process of black music.  Working against the idea that music can be an autonomous thing, the chapters situate meaning in African American musical practice as socially and historically determined through storytelling in the first chapter and through scholarly method in the second.  Each deals with how personal reactions and interpretations are, in the end, socially constituted even in the most “objective” presentation.  Subjectivity is everywhere.  To bring the point home, the musical example “Yearning for Your Love,” a slow jam by the Gap Band became the soundtrack for an important family event, my father’s funeral, the story of which, I tell in the book.  I combine sonic description and social setting as a way to springboard into my framework for a criticism of black music making, one that is less interested in making fetishes of musical works or musicians and more into “how” they mean.

Composer and scholar Olly Wilson wrote an influential article in 1983 titled “Black Music as an Art Form.”  In it he parses the terms “black music” and “art” through an analytical comparison of a work song “Katie Left Memphis” and a Miles Davis jazz recording of the song “Green Dolphin Street.” A groundbreaking thinker in ideas surroundign an African cultural heritage shaping contemporary music, Wilson uses the close analysis of sound to ground his argument.  One of his premises is how perceptual, intrinsic interest (together with African American musical priorities) combine to make Davis’ recording fit into the realm of “art.”  The work song, while also displaying an African sonic legacy, is valued as art primarily because of its utility or “function.” Throughout the course, we will question the mass/folk/art divide, especially through teasing out the utility or functionality of art discourse with regard to black music.

Throughout the course we will take up a number of controversial topics about black music history such as the participation of other ethnic groups, the historical practice and legacy of minstrelsy, the role of commodification and adaptation, and the logic and counter-logic of cultural continuity and historical contingency.

Let’s begin in earnest with an obvious question and answer that I hope will be illuminated over the next few weeks.  What is African American music?  It describes distinct configurations of sound organization linked historically and socially to people of African descent living within the United States.  While scholarship has identified a shared body of conceptual approaches to sound among the numerous idioms of African American music, musicians have employed them across various functional divides in American culture such as written and oral, sacred and secular, art and popular.  Although African American people have been the primary innovators among these idioms, due to mass mediation, the contiguous nature of culture sharing among American ethnic groups, an ever developing and sophisticated global market system, technological advances, and music’s ability to absorb the different meanings ascribed to it, people of all backgrounds have shaped, contributed to, and excelled in this fluid yet distinct body of music making. In addition, many historians of African American music have included the activities of blacks that participated as performers and composers in the Eurological concert tradition under this rubric.

Advertisements

Interstate-57, ML3556, and Drastic Interpretations: Where I’m Coming From

15 Wednesday Jun 2011

Posted by MusiQologY in African American Music, Black Music, Black Music Research, Blues Music, Dr. Guthrie Ramsey, General, The Blues

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Black Music, Charlie Keil, Dena Epstein, Guthrie Ramsey, leroi jones, musicology, Olly Wilson, Portia Maultsby, Samuel Floyd, University of Michigan

Part I

Black Music Month, Day #15

I first discovered the ML3556 section of the library as an undergraduate and grew enamored of

the literature about black music, a topic that truly charged me up academically.   Browsing the stacks became a favorite pastime as I read books by LeRoi Jones, Charlie Keil, Eileen Southern, Dena Epstein, and other trailblazing writers.  Venturing further into this world of letters, I soon learned about journals that featured the work of groundbreaking scholars such as Portia Maultsby, Samuel Floyd, Josephine Wright, and Olly Wilson, all of whom laid the foundation for black music research’s modern era, beginning in the mid-1970s. The present collection of essays of my own contributions to this field—some previously published, others new—represents a partial view of my intellectual journey since those stack-browsing days (and nights!).

Portia Maultsby: Pioneering Scholar of the Contemporary Era of Black Music Research

As I embarked on graduate studies at the University of Michigan in 1989, there was lots of naiveté.  As a gigging pianist and elementary school educator, I possessed drive but lacked a clear sense of what was really at stake, of what the primary arguments defining the field were, and how the study of black music (my primary interest) fit into the larger scheme of things—how it fit, for instance, into what counted as valuable knowledge in the systematic study of music history.   Pursuit of the PhD. was, for me, simply a logical extension of my interests in the power that many experienced in music making and in deep listening.  There was a lot learn.  My traversing and appreciating the space between being, on

Graduate School Ghetto: Insular, Subcultural, Ritualistic

the one hand, a producer of organized sound, and on the other, a contributor to the world of ideas about sound was the first order of business.  And there were, to be sure, many ideas to contend with at that time as musicology scrambled to reshape its profile to be “new,” that is, more inclusive in both topic and methodology.

As I explained in Race Music(2003), I understood early in life that music was an activity that did important cultural work, although I could not have spoken about it in precisely those terms.  Thus, the book opened by recounting some early experiences in African American communal spaces (“community theaters”) and how music informed them.  The extended community into which I was born and raised—the greater South Side of Chicago—had made an imprint on me but had had implications for the study of American music more generally.

The Creators of UpSouth Culture

The post-migrant, Up-South Delta culture of my youth was, indeed, a sprawling and robust black social world.  It comprised housing projects, tenements, two-flats, storefront churches, cathedrals, barber and beauty shops, political machines, sporting cultures, print mass media, parades, and radical bookstores; and its cultural politics ranged from traditional notions of uplift to unapologetic militancy.  Expressive culture abounded in poetry readings and speech recitations on Sunday afternoon church programs. Street theaters, discos, live music venues, and even high school music programs all specialized in circulating their own brand of music and dance “literacies.”  At communal performance spaces like “midnight” roller rink sessions and

Home, Sweet Tenement: The Living Was Good But Not Easy

church musicals; and in local college gospel choirs and jazz ensembles—we experienced a dynamic social world saturated in cultural forms that worked together to produce a feeling, a structure, an atmosphere in which “blackness” was practiced as a way of being in and thinking about the world.  Not as wholly deterministic, but as a range of options for making identifications.

Of course, the serendipity of one’s birth—no matter how germane to the topic of one’s study—does not solely a scholar make.  Some would even fear that this proximity might endanger the sanctity, objectivity, or even ethics of the process.  Indeed, the fact remains: for every instance of on-the-ground culture-making taking place internally in black Chicago, to the scholar, its social world has been equally “made” by the city’s formal study.  Chicago—particularly its black component—has been the focus of myriad sociological investigations—I’m thinking here most prominently of St Clair Drake and Horace Cayton’s monumental Black Metropolis (1945).  Studies like these have helped to make it the perennial black metropolis of the ethnographic imagination.  With such intensive “making” on either side of this social ledger, the relationship between the studied and the ones doing the studying seems to be one of interdependence, and as such, renders any “insider” status but one point of entry into this topic.  Understanding the relationship between these two aspects of the equation has fascinated me and, as readers will see, it has animated some of my published work, hopefully productively so.

Most of the writing that inspired me was produced during the Black Consciousness period in

Ethnographic Truths: Telling It Like It Is

American history, from the mid-1960s through the 1970s.  While I didn’t engage this literature until some years after it first appeared, the work reminded me of my coming-of-age years, a time in which culture and politics were often entwined with combustion.   Recently while speaking to a colleague in another discipline, an expert in architecture and the cultural politics of urban space, I recalled one of the urban legends we were told heard as young teenagers.  In the basement of a “black book” store lined with literature, incense, posters and the ubiquitous colors of “black liberation”—red, black, and green—some comrades and I were directed to a wall splayed with maps of our surrounding area.  The intense, Afro-ed, twenty-something young man who was directing our “tour” of the space stressed to us, his young and rapt audience, that “the Man’s” plan to extend Interstate 57 into our neighborhood was a ploy to contain our community with military force when “the Revolution” finally hit.  I told this story to my colleague with an air of incredulity. I was taken aback when she, an Australian, said—with no sense of irony—that the ominous sounding plan was at least part of the reason for that highway.

As I reflect back, I realize now that experiences like these—and there were many more—influenced me musically, intellectually, and socially.  I’ve embraced them as a baseline worldview that, for better or worse, has informed the political shades of my musical writing.  I have continually sought out ways to participate in a “project musicology” that would push out at the edges of the standard, “objective,” narrative mode.  Indeed, if nothing else, one of the things I took from those I-57 days was that freedom needed to be pursued at all costs, and that it was always a pressing matter.

Are We All Blues People? A Conversation on NPR

17 Wednesday Nov 2010

Posted by MusiQologY in Blues Music, Gospel

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Blues, blues people, erykah badu, Guthrie Ramsey, karen clark sheard, leroi jones, npr

When you say blues, many people think of an historical genre of the American past.  In his 1963 classic book Blues People, a young, and then uncontroversial, LeRoi Jones wrote so eloquently about the blues aesthetic in black vernacular music that the

Everybody Needs the Blues

book is used almost as a “passport to adventure” in contemporary studies of African American music.  Indeed, the blues have informed many genres—rock, gospel, jazz, and extends to even hip-hop.

Although rooted in African American communities of the early 20th century, the blues’ influence has since its inception become a cross-cultural, intra-ethnic, poly-nation, and very fluid phenomenon, with too many iterations, versions, and inversions to name.  Click to hear a conversation I had on NPR recently about how we can all be considered “blues people” when you consider the matter closely.

In the controversial video “Window Seat, a work that she described as installation art, Erykah Badu, the modern hoodoo blues woman, is all fed up and sighs:

“On this porch I’m rockin’ by and forth like Lightnin’ Hopkins, can somebody speak to Scotty and beam me up…”

On the other hand, a powerful Karen Clark Sheard, the undisputed top-of-line gospel diva, sanctifies and then electrifies blues tributaries in “Couldn’t Help It If I Tried.” Buckle your seat belts, kids, she ain’t playing with this stuff.

Dr. Guy

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 111 other followers

Twitter Updates

  • RT @Tacumasong: @MusiqologyBlog @antiddote @WilkinsImmanuel @ArnettaJohnson1 @DrGuyMusiQology Look forward to checking it - J. Michael Harr… 1 day ago
  • RT @CRWikeley: The musicologist and the podcast guzzler in me are so happy rn We need more content like this Amazing show @DrGuyMusiQolog… 1 day ago
  • RT @sgeelow: @CRWikeley @DrGuyMusiQology Ooh will check this out - have been on the hunt for a good musicological podcast! 1 day ago
  • RT @MusiqologyBlog: .@DrGuyMusiQology from the archives! twitter.com/MusiqologyBlog… 1 day ago
  • RT @JohnVilanova: New from me on @DrGuyMusiQology's @MusiqologyBlog. A Philly history lesson with @WRTImusic's J. Michael Harrison. Listen… 1 day ago

Categories

Recent Posts

  • 42, Jackie Robinson and the Aesthetics of Integration
  • White Man Dance! Justin Timberlake and the Strange Career of Blue-Eyed Soul
  • Special “New Black Man” Feature : It’s Just a Song? Guthrie Ramsey on the Context(s) of Beyonce’s “Bow Down”
  • The Feminist Wire Excerpt: Bebop, Jazz Manhood and “Piano Shame”
  • Amiri Baraka + Guthrie Ramsey at World Café Live

Alicia Hall Moran Amiri Baraka Bebop Black Music Black Radio Blues Bridget Ramsey Bud Powell Chicago Chris' Jazz Cafe Chrisette Michele Civil Rights Movement Colored Waiting Room Curtis Mayfield Denise King Dr. Guthrie Ramsey Dr. Guy's MusiQology Elizabeth Alexander erykah badu film Funk Gospel Gospel Music Grammy's Guthrie Ramsey Hettie Jones Hip-Hop Improvisation James Brown jason moran Jazz Jazz & the Word Series jerry thompson Kellie Jones Kennedy Center Kenny Davis Langston Hughes Ledisi leroi jones Live Music Mahalia Jackson Mark Anthony Neal Marvin Gaye Meshell Ndegeocello Michael Jackson Miles Davis Motown musicology MusiQology New York Times Nina Simone Opera Philadelphia Pop Music R&B Ramsey Lewis Rap Reggae Robert Glasper Robert Glasper Experiment Samuel Floyd Soul Stevie Wonder Stolen Moments The Beatles The Blues The Chicago Project The Clark Sisters The Colored Waiting Room The Rolling Stones Tukufu Zuberi Twinkie Clark University of Pennsylvania Washington DC Wynton Marsalis

Links

  • Dr. Guy's MusiQology – Dr. Guthrie Ramsey Facebook Page
  • Dr. Guy's MusiQology Myspace

MusiQologY

The Band Where Music's Past and Present Collide
Advertisements

Links

  • Dr. Guy's MusiQology – Dr. Guthrie Ramsey Facebook Page
  • Dr. Guy's MusiQology Myspace

Blog at WordPress.com.

Cancel